Local Yarn Stores of Central NY
I am fortunate enough to have not 1, not 2, but 3 local yarn stores near me in the greater Syracuse area! This isn't a comprehensive list of Central NY yarn stores—there is one in New Hartford that I plan on checking out next time I drive out there for Nothing Bundt Cakes. But for now, here's a look at the local yarn stores within a reasonable driving distance from me.
Knitty Gritty — Liverpool, NY
Praises
This is my most local yarn store! It’s about a 15 minute drive from my house and it’s genuinely walkable from my dad’s house. Out of these 3 yarn stores, this one has the easiest and most spacious parking lot. Also, all these yarn stores have areas for crafters to come and work on their projects and this one appears to have the most comfortable seating options. They have tons of swatches all over the place, so you can see how all the variegated and self-striping yarns work up. They also have test-knitting samples where you can actually work with the yarn and see how it feels to knit with before buying, something I didn’t see in the other stores. I can’t speak for any other rewards programs, but I will say Knitty Gritty’s birthday reward is $20 off. In the year of 10% off instead of what used to be a free drink, it feels very generous—and you don’t need to purchase anything that calendar year or spend a minimum amount to redeem it. It’s how I ended up justifying a $60 skein of Juniper Moon Farm Glimmer earlier this year. They also have a good website that is often up to date and accurate to their actual stock.
Complaints
My number one biggest complaint is how painfully silent this place normally is. That’s how I advertised it to my friend Megan when I forced her there on my birthday. If there is any music playing at all, it’s usually set to a very low volume. It also has a very open floor plan, which makes the comfortable seating area slightly less appealing to me personally. Between the open floor plan and the fact that I can hear every step I take, I feel conspicuous taking my time to browse. Most of the time if I’m going to go there, I’m going there on a mission for something I saw on their website. As far as yarn selection goes, this is maybe my least favorite of the 3, but it changes and is still better than Michaels or Hobby Lobby.
Jamesville Yarn Cupboard — Jamesville, NY
Praises
What makes Jamesville Yarn Cupboard worth the 25 minute drive is their insane selection of yarns I can’t get anywhere else near me. They have a ton of brands that I recognize from shopping online or as recommended yarn in patterns, but never get to see in person—brands such as Isager, Knitting For Olive, Malabrigo, Sandnes Garn. This store is actually the only way I ever was and ever would have been introduced to Urth 16. Because the price tag feels really steep for what it is until you actually touch the skein, and then you understand. I could have walked in and bought all 3 Isager yarns that are recommended for the Ava Jacket.
Complaints
Despite having the most impressive yarn selection of these 3 stores, it is by far my least favorite shopping experience. The parking lot feels like you’re driving somewhere you shouldn’t be. There’s a bunch of yarn crammed into a very tight space, which not only makes it easy to overlook things such as the small selection of Malabrigo Rios, but it also makes you feel like you’re being watched the entire time you browse. The way their button selection is stored makes them cumbersome to browse, and so I didn’t. They had a bunch of different sock kits that I genuinely might have been interested in buying if I didn’t have to ask the price on them. I actually didn’t see price tags on anything, and if I have to ask how much something costs, I’m probably going to rule it out before I even consider buying it. If this complaint section feels long, it’s because I feel frustration over wasted potential. They have the inventory of a place I’d love, but I don’t love it there.
Oliver’s Originals — Manlius, NY
Praises
This was my first time going to Oliver’s Originals and I will be back! It’s a bit of a hike to Manlius, but they make up for that fact in so many ways. I was greeted kindly with a hello and then left the hell alone to browse—I loved that. It is set up in a way that makes browsing feel enjoyable. There are a couple different rooms to move through, corners where you can browse and feel concealed, and there was actual music playing. Easily the most extensive and well-displayed button section out of the 3 stores. There’s also a large selection of the boring tools and notions that I would love to not be at the mercy of Amazon shipping for, such as ChiaoGoo needles/cables and Soak wool wash. They have lots of locally hand-dyed yarn such as their own Oliver’s Originals brand and Spun Right Round from Rochester. Lastly, they have a bunch of other fun stuff for gifting like bags, socks, felting kits, and cute bars of hand soap. Nothing and nobody made me feel like I needed to hurry along my browsing, and I ended up spending some money on stuff I don’t need and I wouldn’t have it any other way.
Complaints
I have a very minor issue with the size of their parking lot, but other than that my biggest complaint is distance. Knitty Gritty is close enough to be a place I could stop at; I need to intentionally take a trip to Oliver’s Originals. And this isn’t a complaint towards the store, but I am complaining that I couldn’t really buy any yarn due to Christmas coming up, so I will have to go back.
* * *
All the complaints I’ve listed here are said with absolute love, and an acknowledgment of privilege. I know some people are stuck with nothing more than a Hobby Lobby now that Joann’s is gone. I find it ridiculous, because yarn is exactly the type of product I’d prefer to shop for in person. I’d love to be able to see what the color looks like rather than comparing the lighting of 17 different Ravelry projects. I’d love to be able to feel the yarn and see if it’s soft before spending over $100 on a deconstructed sweater. I have strong opinions because I genuinely care about the existence of these stores, and I’m glad to have the opportunity to visit all 3 of them.
P.S. I might be skipping every other week on the blog until my Christmas presents are done. If there’s not a post next week, that’s why. :)























Comments
Post a Comment